“Looking for a story”
Posted in General Musings on December 30th, 2009 by Big Ed – Be the first to commentSorry–couldn’t resist. Two of the yahoo groups I belong to had nearly identical posts, from different people, with that title. Such posts occur almost like clockwork. At least once a month, someone will post “I’m looking for a story where xxx and yyyy occurred” and hope that the denizens of the erotica group du jour recognize the story and can provide title, author, and site.
At first, I found such posts great–they seemed to be a good way of helping readers. Then I became annoyed–can’t people bookmark or download stories into their own libraries? It isn’t that hard. These days I’m mostly amused because I realized a handful of implications of such posts.
The first is that anyone actually “looking for a story” much read a lot of stories. I think it’s a lot harder to forget the name of a story you’ve read if you’ve only read a half dozen in the past year. I don’t know what the threshold is, but they can’t ‘blend together’ if there aren’t that many to blend together.
Now admittedly, there’s a time factor involved. It’s much easier to forget titles of stories read years ago than one read yesterday. But there’s still a need for the reader to have read many. If they’ve only read two books in the past five years, the odds are pretty good that, even if they can’t recall the title, they can recall where they got the book or where it’s likely to be now. But even with the time factor–the implication is pretty clear–these people “looking for a story” are very likely to be heavy readers.
Which means they’re fans of the genre. I’ve read maybe one Western in my life. I’ve read more science fiction than I can count. So which is genre is going to contain a story that’s memorable enough for me to recall plot and character details, but that I can’t place exactly? Again, the one with more stories I’ve read.
Complete aside–I do recognize the phenomena known as “misplaced in the library.” My wife and I own 8 seven foot tall bookcases, that are overflowing. And when the toddler came along, lower shelves got emptied and shoved into higher shelves willy-nilly. I have no idea what we own anymore. So I could easily some day ask about a book I actually happen to own.
Having fans of the genre I write in (and read in) is just cool. This is a communication medium, after all, and doing art that no one sees (or reads) is kind of pointless.
The second implication is that some of these stories have lasting power. They’re not ‘read and forget.’ This may be because of the characters and overall story, or it may be because there’s a really hot sex scene that the reader doesn’t want to explicitly mention in their request for help, but there’s something that tugs them back to wanting to reread the story. Stories memorable enough and/or good enough to be reread are just cool.
Second complete aside–I have a shelf that is “meaningful books.” It’s intentionally only one shelf, filled with the books that have had the biggest impact on my thinking and my life. It’s sometimes gratifying to see them sitting next to each other that way, as silent markers of contemplations past.
Which leads to the third implication–they’re not asking for my stories. I’ve seen only one “looking for a story” request for one of my stories in five years. Which means that either my stories are eminently forgettable, or my readers are remembering who wrote them and where to find them.
Now obviously there’s a ‘selection bias’ in that last implication. People who ask the question in yahoogroups where I post are likely to not forget who I am. They are therefore less likely to forget what stories are mine. I’m sure that if there’s someone scratching their head somewhere about a story I wrote, they’ll ultimately post their question in a different forum.
But it’s still cool. If my stuff sticks, it sticks well enough that people don’t need to ask about it later. And that, ultimately is part of what I’m trying to accomplish.
Big Ed's Place