I’ve been cleaning the basement the past few days. Not the general sweeping and such, but the type of cleaning that involves opening boxes that have sat undisturbed and undusted for nearly a decade. Of course, that means subjecting myself to waves of nostalgia, both good and the bad.
If I step back, I find my reactions somewhat amusing. Why are the pangs of regret over missed opportunities and bad misdeeds so strong? My life is in a good place, and I seriously doubt that going back in time and ‘doing things over’ would meaningfully improve them. In a couple of cases, mostly around past relationships, I know I’m far better off with my wife than I ever would have been with those women. It’s not that they were bad women, or even necessarily bad fits with me. It’s just that I am a better man now, and a much better husband, than I think I ever would have been with them.
For example, I stumbled across some old letters from the woman who was the basis for “Tina.” Unlike in Friends and Benefits, there was no reconciliation with her, and I have not seen or spoken with her in thirteen years. That said, in the modern era of google and facebook, it wasn’t too hard to discover that she’s alive and married and living halfway across the country from where we had our romance. Sometimes I like to kid myself that we’d have continued having torrid sex if we’d stuck together, even though I know that is usually not a constant in any relationship. But at the same time, I realize I’m glossing over all the things that didn’t work between us, and led to our split. Would I have ‘grown up’ if she hadn’t thrown me out of her life? Somehow I suspect not. Or at least not with the same level of maturity and insight I now have.
Which makes it interesting to consider the subgenre of time travel that pops up at storiesonline and sometimes in mainstream fiction. If you could go back and do it all over again, would you? And if not, would you write about it? Numerous authors have come to varied answers to the first, while indulging in the second.
But me… even in these eddies of remembrance, I don’t feel the urge to rewrite my past. At least not more than I’ve done.
Admittedly, I’m mining my past pretty heavily for my fiction, because ‘what if?’ is a great starting point for an idea that turns into a story. But it’s not a close what if, and it’s not personal. It’s more, “this would make a cool story.”
For example, I once had a date with a woman I met at a party. I asked her over dinner what she did for a living and she said, “Well, I’m a phone sex operator. I never graduated college and I found that phone sex was the most money for the hour.” Now I don’t need to write a rehash how the relationship went (good first two dates, bad third date, no fourth date). Nor do I even have to create a story where our relationship took off.
Instead… what if, instead of me sitting across from her, it was a shy, nerdy guy? Or a sexually conservative guy? Or a guy with a fetish for phone sex himself? Or what if, instead of meeting at a party, they were set up by a mutual friend? Or (gasp) a relative? Or they met through a chatroom online? And what if she was doing phone sex for kicks instead of the money? Or she wanted to get out of it, but didn’t know how?
The creative possibilities are far more interesting that simply rewriting what happened. And while this story isn’t in my queue, it’s the type of thing that often occurs to me when these maudlin moments hit. And so writing seems to be one way to help pop me out of the past and start thinking about what I might do (or write) next.