One of the side effects of story codes (blogged about here), I believe, is the growth of stories with taboo elements in them. I’m primarily referring to incest, bestiality, and rape stories here, since necrophilia and the various scat type stories still seem to occupy a very small niche. The reason is, as I mentioned previously, is that it’s now easy to search for codes. So if a reader gets a jolt from a taboo, they can easily find a lot more stories with that same taboo. Therefore, in a classic feedback loop, if a writer on a free site wants more readers, they need to incorporate the codes that people are searching for.
I.e., more searching for the taboo leads to more stories with the taboo.
Now erotica about these taboos is certainly not new. Bestiality, incest, and rape can all be found in Greek myths, Victorian era porn, and the various underground porn comics and novels available for most of the 20th century. Heck, your local adult news stand probably has letters magazines devoted to incest and Penthouse Variations even published some woman-dog letters in the mid-70′s.
So did the internet change anything? Yep. Availability.
Porn on the internet is easy to find these days. It’s easy to get just about any variant of porn with judicious googling or a willingness to wade through spam and sleazy sites. Heck, someone’s been googling “toddler erotica” and turning up my site (there’s an old blog post about me having a toddler that’s turning up and my stats tracker tells me how people get here). Furthermore, it’s easy to stumble across new types of porn. You don’t have to be looking for stories about the taboos to find them on the free sites.
So… those women-dog stories I stumbled across long ago and couldn’t find again if my life depended on it? Well, anyone can find a few thousand woman-dog stories with a few clicks of the mouse. And so if someone gets turned on… we’re in that feedback loop again. The internet will provide that for which people seek.
This is, of course, not limited to porn. The internet makes all niche areas easier to access, and communities easier to form. If you’re into yak herding or flying experimental helium balloons, you’re much more likely to find information and community online than in your local physical neighborhood. This is, in general, a good thing.
So… is the availability of taboo porn a bad thing? On the one hand, there’s an argument that increased exposure desensitizes. We’re less likely to be outraged over taboo acts if we’ve read a hundred stories involving them. Also, the constant “hit” can be addictive for some people (and that’s for a future post).
On the other hand… most people are perfectly capable of separating fantasy and real life. They can handle the idea of being turned on by a taboo and still never want to do it in real life. I’m also very suspicious of those who want regulations or laws that restrict the ‘most’ for the few that have trouble separating fantasy and real life. As soon as we move into trying to restrict the market and exchange of ideas, we’re perilously close to creating ‘thoughtcrimes.’ It’s not too far a slide down the old slippery slope to move from trying to criminalize discussions of rape fantasies to trying to criminalize discussions of fantasies about killing politicians to trying to criminalize fantasies about opposing politicians. Ask the Dixie Chicks what they went through for opposing Bush, and imagine the force of law and police behind it. As I wrote in my first post, freedom really starts in the bedroom. And that includes the freedom to fantasize.
Furthermore, I suspect the lure of the taboo porn will also prove to be somewhat cyclical. A lot of the attraction (discussed in a future post) is because it’s new. Based on my own experiences and those of people I’ve discussed porn with, it’ll fade. It doesn’t take too long reading those hundreds of taboo stories to realize that most of them are crap, and then to reach the point where quality is more important than the story codes.
At least I hope so. Because in my writing, I (generally) want to be realistic and capture sex as it is or could be. While I will occasionally touch on a taboo, it’s because I want to play with some related aspect of sexuality, rather than the taboo itself. Does that mean that I too am increasing the amount of taboo porn on the internet? Yeah, I guess it does. But maybe by having quality writing that also goes into the implications of the taboo, it won’t increase the desensitization. We’ll have to see.