I may have spent my twenties thinking I was ugly (see my post here), but life changed in my thirties. Not my appearance so much as my attitude. And the defining moment was a conversation with an acquaintance who became a friend.
In my early 30′s, I started exploring tantra and bdsm. I also studied David Deida’s work, though these days I do not have the unbridled enthusiasm for his work that I did then. I wasn’t completely celibate during that time, though I didn’t have any regular lovers either. It was one of those occasional ‘friends with benefits’ that suggested I spend some time with “William.”
William and I met for an early dinner at a neighborhood Italian restaurant not too far from my house. We talked about a variety of things, but eventually the conversation circled around to my frustrations in dating, and in my self-perceived unattractiveness. We kept our voices low because, while the restaurant was not full, we were the only men in the place, including the visible staff.
William noted this and circled his finger to indicate the room. “The reality is,” he said, “you can have any woman in this room. Even the married ones. The question is–which one and why?”
I was gobsmacked. On the surface, that statement seemed ludicrous, but deep down, I knew it was more true than false.
That truth hit me on many levels. First, it attacks the concept that sex was ‘scarce.’ That’s a cultural construct that seems less true with every passing generation these days, but the truth is that it’s a lie. Any guy–and any gal–can get laid if they truly want to. It’s just a matter of what constraints they put on the act. For example, a woman, no matter how ugly or fat, could walk down to a bar and offer sex to anyone who wants it, and it’d happen. Similarly, a man can get laid in most cities for a few hundred dollars and a phone call. The constraints of “have to like the guy” or “not gonna pay for it” are what make sex more scarce.
So, what made it scarce in the restaurant? Mostly the constraints I was placing on myself. “It wasn’t right to try to pick up a stranger.” “I shouldn’t flirt with waitresses.” “Ooh, she’s not gonna be interested, I shouldn’t even try.”
That last one is a killer. It brought back memories of high school when all my friends were lusting after a cheerleader “Karen.” Toward the end of our senior year, “Karen” revealed that the only reason she’d ever gone out with her boyfriend was because he had been the only guy to ever ask her out. She would have loved to have gone on dates with my friends, but their own “I’m not good enough for her” is what prevented them from getting a date with her.
This is not a problem that pickup artists have. A true pickup artist knows that it’s really not about him–it’s about the image of him in the woman’s mind (and vice versa when the genders are reversed). If she sees him as exciting, or mysterious, or funny, or whatever it is that turns her on, she’ll overlook the receding hairline and the asymmetrical ears. A true pickup artist plays to his target’s fantasies and desires and lets it roll from there.
Which was part of William’s point. It wasn’t the scarcity of sex that was holding me back, but my own efforts or lack thereof. Furthermore, I wasn’t a fumbling teenager with no skills around women. I knew enough about paying attention, projecting strong masculine energy, being present, etc. to be capable of being a pickup artist. That was the second truth that whapped me upside the head. Maybe seducing a woman would have been a problem when I was 18, but I wasn’t 18 anymore. It was time to treat women, be it during sex and seduction or simple interactions, by being a man instead of a boy.
Now, of course, that doesn’t mean that I could automatically persuade any of the women in the restaurant to have a quickie in the bathroom. What a given woman finds seductive is very personal. It might be a zipless fuck with a man she just met, but it might be roses and love poems and a long slow seduction with hints of marriage, like in many romance novels. The latter takes a lot more time to build and develop, but is still possible for a pickup artist.
Which is why the second part of the sentence also hit my profoundly. “Which one and why?” There’s a huge difference between picking the woman just looking for a quickie good time and picking the married woman who’s unhappy because her husband’s neglecting her and who might be intrigued by a prospective husband #2. To an amoral pickup artist, the distinction might not matter, but to me, it did. My “why” had to be more than “because I thought she’d be a good fuck.”
There are ways, of course, to be an ethical slut, to have an honorable one night stand, and to serve another person sexually without any intent of becoming husband #2. I don’t need to review them here, but simply state that all of them require considering the other person as a person, and not just a target or a score.
Of course, that conversation with William didn’t turn my life around immediately. I still made mistakes in life and in dating, and struggled to accept what I’d realized was true. I had many days where I slid back into old mental patterns instead of sticking with the new ones–that it wasn’t the women, and it wasn’t my looks that mattered. It was my energy and my actions. But, eventually, it sunk in.
By the time I was 34, my life was full of playmates and lovers, all of whom I dealt with in high integrity. Then, at 35, I met the woman who became my wife. The ‘why’ was different, and that made all the difference in how I approached her and what happened after.
As a coda, my wife rolled her eyes when she read The Ugly One, written well after we were engaged. She’d never noticed my ‘deformities’ at all–to her I was, and am, simply handsome.