Online personas and emotional privacy
Posted in General Musings on April 28th, 2010 by Big Ed – Be the first to commentRemittance Girl recently posted about disclosure, and mused about her own need for emotional privacy, even in blogging and writing. I was touched. As writers, and online bloggers, we tread a fine line between revealing all and maintaining that private space which sustains us and often serves as the wellspring of our best work.
I’ve wondered about it myself quite a bit. Where exactly is the line?
Now many of us maintain online personas that are separate from our daily lives. I try to, though it’s not easy. There are perhaps 20 or 30 people from my daily life who know about this site because I’ve told them. There’s at least one person who found my site first and figured out who I was. Most people I don’t tell, but wouldn’t be too put out if they connected my identities. However, there are probably another dozen people who I absolutely don’t want to connect the two.
That latter list is why I recently did all the legal paperwork so I can do finances and contracts as “Ed Magusson.” It cost me a fair amount of money, but makes me feel a little more secure. I don’t have to worry about someone making a tip jar donation and then realizing that we work together or live in the same neighborhood in exchange.
But that just makes it harder to connect my online persona with the one that drops my son off at daycare, not impossible. A serious investigator could go through my posts and my stories and do a pretty good job of triangulating who I am (that is not a challenge, btw).
So I sometimes wonder what details I should obfuscate and which are okay (note: some are intentionally incorrect specifically to make it difficult for any determined investigators). It’s not always an easy call. Admitting I live in Colorado narrows me down to one of five million people. That’s probably not an issue. Besides, it doesn’t take too many of my stories to figure it out anyway. But my career field? My views on local politics?
The thing is… some of these details are important for stories that contain emotional honesty. I really can’t blog about some of my frustrations in writing without mentioning I have a toddler. It’s just too key–he’s frustrating, wonderful, and exhausting. It drives me nuts that taking care of him cuts into my writing, but there’s absolutely no way I’d want it the other way around, where my writing cut into taking care of him. So if I want to share the part of my soul that’s writhing into knots about not writing–well, I have to share that detail.
Similarly, there’s an emotional honesty in my fiction that can only come from having been there, done that. Now I haven’t done everything I write about–then this would be memoir instead of fiction. But I cull enough real situations to infuse them with honest emotion, as best as my wordsmithing allows.
The Ugly One wouldn’t be the same if I had been born beautiful (as my son seems to have done, but as his Dad, I might not be objective here). Friends and Benefits wouldn’t be the same if I hadn’t had a relationship like the one Joe had with Sharon. My shorter stories have pieces of me in them as well, to varying degrees of depth. I don’t always plumb the emotional depths, after all Dr. Seuss Provides the Girls isn’t exactly Shakespeare or even Theodor Geisel. But there are still pieces of my mind emotional state in even it. Three women at once? Hey, I understand that temptation. It’s real even if it’s light.
But there’s a level of privacy there still. I don’t have to admit which parts are drawn from the depths and which are solely figments of my imagination. I don’t have to even put it there in the first place. But obviously I do put it there, and even admit to it later.
So where’s the line? I think it’s different for every author, so that question is… where is it for me?
I’m still pondering that with just about every story or “my history” post.
Big Ed's Place