The present I really want
Posted in General Musings on December 28th, 2011 by Big Ed – 2 CommentsAnother Christmas is over and once again, too many material goods were exchanged. Economists sometimes write about how inefficient this exchange is economically. We give people things they don’t really want or won’t really use, when cash would serve them better. However, cash is considered poor taste.
This is in many ways because giving gifts is, for many people, a way they demonstrate their love. The problem is that it’s usually the circumstances around the gift that form that demonstration rather than the demonstration itself. For example, I’ve noticed that women appreciate flowers when they’re given on random days rather than specific holidays. Roses on Valentine’s Day convey the message, “I didn’t forget the holiday but didn’t think of something you’d like more than a traditional offering.” Roses on a Thursday in March convey the message, “I was thinking of you and I wanted to make an effort to make you happy, just ’cause.” Which represents love better?
At Christmas, the ‘love’ is often conveyed in the number of presents or the price of the presents if we listen to the Madison Avenue marketers. Love is also conveyed when the giver correctly picks something that the receiver will really like. The message is, “I know you well enough to know what you would like.” Unfortunately, this can be very very hard.
For one, the receiver themselves may not know what they would like. I want an ereader, but there’s no way my wife could guess which one since I don’t know. Needless to say, she decided not to guess, for which I am grateful.
For two, how many people do we give gifts to that we don’t really know? We buy presents for my wife’s aunt, who we see maybe twice a year. We have a general list of her interests, but that’s really not good enough to know that, “yes, she’d really like this and it won’t end up in her junk drawer.”
Finally, there are usually other constraints in play as well. Equivalent cost reciprocity drives me nuts. If I find a work of blown glass that I do happen to know my father would love, but it exceeds a given dollar amount, I have to pass it up. Yes, he’d enjoy the present, but the mismatch in value between the gift I give him and the gift I give my sister would cause problems. Similarly, no one wants to “make them feel bad” if they get you a cheap gift when you get them an expensive gift. It’s a gift, folks, not a barter exchange. Why does the relative cost matter? But it does.
In the process, I’ve become difficult to buy for. I’m at a point economically in my life where anything I want materially, I can just buy. When people ask me for my wish list, it therefore becomes, “stuff that’s either too unimportant for me to purchase, or too much of a pain to shop for.” Yeah, give me a gift that I couldn’t be bothered to buy myself. That’s what I want and a good demonstration of love, right?
Now I figured this out long ago, but it never alleviated the question “what do you want?” For lovers, I’d say, “lingerie in your size.” I.e., the best gift you can give me is to fuck my brains out. That worked up until we had kids. As much as my wife might want to fuck my brains out as a Christmas gift, it’s kind of difficult when the baby is insisting on nursing and the 3-year-old wants to see if Santa came. It’s also not a present I can open when the extended family is gathered around the tree.
Which has led to me to realize that the gift I really want is time. Want to make me happy and show you love me? Volunteer to babysit. Offer to take over a home repair or a chore like getting my car washed. Bring food over for a meal. Help me free up the time so I can go fuck my wife’s brains out, or go sit in a coffee shop and write, or do all the things I enjoy doing but get shoved aside trying to raise children and get through the day.
I’ve started to say that, when people ask what I want. Some get it–this year I got babysitting gift certificates from one relative. Most–still don’t. Instead, the mound of stuff just grew, and I lost time figuring out where to put it and what to do with it, that I didn’t really want to give up.
Anyway, it’s over, and now we just have to clean up and start the new year. Hopefully there will be more time to do fun things in the coming months.
Big Ed's Place


